I had to share a great moment!! Lily, who continues to work on her potty training, has been better in general. But TODAY, I put her little xpen on the porch with the revamped potty tray from petsmart ( handles removed). Looking at all suggestions, I made the xpen tiny and wedged the tray across the pen so she could hardly miss. ( at this point, no litter or pad, just to get her on it). It has been pouring in nc today and I’ve had a bad cold. Lily and I were under the roofed area of our deck. With guidance and a leash to help, she has used her tray three times even the restricted circling for pooping. I threw a huge celebration each time and after the poop event I gave her her first bully stick. She is in Heaven, and I am, too!!!!