I agree, though when it comes to actual dollars and cents, I keep running the numbers and self insuring is still cheaper, especially if you have multiple dogs. Assuming you HAVE the money set aside, and are disciplined about it.
I think it makes a HUGE amount of sense to insure puppies for their first few years. That is when you are likely to get hit by anything genetic, and “stupid puppy stuff”. And premiums are low. Then you hit years of rising premiums (with most companies) and the majority of dogs are relatively healthy. (If your dog is not, by all means KEEP his insurance!!!) when they get old, the premiums get exorbitant with many companies, and just when you are most likely to need it, people are priced out of the market.
I think it makes a HUGE amount of sense to insure puppies for their first few years. That is when you are likely to get hit by anything genetic, and “stupid puppy stuff”. And premiums are low. Then you hit years of rising premiums (with most companies) and the majority of dogs are relatively healthy. (If your dog is not, by all means KEEP his insurance!!!) when they get old, the premiums get exorbitant with many companies, and just when you are most likely to need it, people are priced out of the market.